[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [edict-jmdict] Formatting of explanations of technical terms?



G'day,

I think 2b is the best bet (although 2a should also be OK).  The main motivation for splitting the explanation and translation is for people using Edict in reverse (English-Japanese) or for MT.  In these cases you want to match on "occur frequently", not on "occur frequently (...)".    For presenting to people, it is relatively easy to show as "Translation (expl)" by post-processing if desired.  I don't think there is a recommendation for ordering, last feels natural, but I can't think of any really good reason for preferring one to the other.

Francis




On 28 April 2012 15:06, Nils Roland Barth <jmdict.nbarth@********> wrote:
 

A question:
How should we format technical terms,
where there is a strict (terse, technical) translation,
but it requires explanation to be understandable?

Some approaches:
1. Give a short term, with a parenthetical explanation, all in one gloss.
2. Give a short term, and an explanation in a separate gloss,
tagged as [expl]

I’ve generally been doing 1 (short (+ expl)), which seems a
common format, but I was wondering if it would be more correct
to use 2 (separate expl), which I’ve seen used mostly for
idioms.

Also, if using [expl], should [expl] come last? first?
(I try to have the first gloss be understandable, but
explations tend to come afterwards.)

Concretely, I was formatting 好発 (entry 1094053)
http://www.edrdg.org/jmdictdb/cgi-bin/entr.py?e=1094053&svc=jmdict&sid=
and was wondering which of these is best (or something else?):
(all flagged as [fld=med])

1.
occur frequently (age, body part, group of people, etc. in which a
disease or condition occurs especially frequently);
susceptible

2a ([expl] first)
[expl] age, body part, group of people, etc. in which a disease
or condition occurs especially frequently;
occur frequently;
susceptible

2b ([expl] last)
occur frequently;
susceptible;
[expl] age, body part, group of people, etc. in which a disease
or condition occurs especially frequently

宜しく

best,
~nils




--
Francis Bond <http://www3.ntu.edu.sg/home/fcbond/>
Division of Linguistics and Multilingual Studies
Nanyang Technological University